► Show Top 10 Hot Links

Posts Tagged ‘Goldstone Report’

Mr. Goldstone, How Do You Propose To Make It Right For Israel?

by Flyovercountry ( 83 Comments › )
Filed under Gaza, Israel, Leftist-Islamic Alliance, Palestinians, Politics, United Nations at April 7th, 2011 - 5:00 pm

There is so much that is disturbing about this chain of events, I might miss a few points. Please feel free to add to my list in the comments section below. first off, I am not buying the, “I didn’t know any better,” defense of his slanderous attack on Israel being offered by Mr. Goldstone. When he wrote his report on the 2008 – 2009 Gaza offensive, Mr. Goldstone neglected to notice that the practitioners of the Religion of Peace had in fact been actively engaged in kidnapping innocent Israelis and lobbing Katusha Rockets into Northern Israel targeting schools and synagogues daily. He accused Israel of war crimes, and glossed over the fact that war crimes had indeed been perpetrated by the, “Palestinians.” Now, three years later, Mr. Goldstone admits that there were no war crimes committed by the Israelis, and in fact those accusations were entirely fabricated. Now that the damage is done, Goldstone wants to apologize, and travel to Israel, like it never happened. Such is the case for Israel, they literally are held under a different microscope than the rest of the world. There is not a single other nation on Earth who would tolerate the attacks on their soil even once, let alone on a daily basis.  Israel has, as does every nation, the right to defend herself, and yet, I hear calls for Israel to show restraint.  Not only is Israel restrained from defending herself, but she is also the only nation to provide a 24 hour notice of warning to the enemy prior to making any attack during battle.  This insane rule of engagement is designed to prevent anyone from being able to make the charge that Israel targets civilians.  What Goldstone has taught us, is that an actual crime is not necessary for a charge to be levelled.

The U.S. response to this has been, to say the least puzzling.  On the one hand, our U.N. ambassador is giving lip service to being supportive of Israel, but that is where it stops.  By merely wishing the fabricated report to just go away, rather than publicly correct the record, Rice is in effect passing up an opportunity to show the U.N. Human Rights Council, (a body which once boasted as having Moamar Kaddafy as its leader,) for what it truly is.  For those who don’t know, it is a vile collection of the world’s most murderous thugs and brutal dictators given a platform to bully and cajole the law abiding citizens of the world.  The Obma led Kumbayah school of foreign policy has not made any of this better.  In fact, we have seen the most brutal and terrifying organization in world history already take over Egypt, a former ally, and are indeed fighting alongside this same group to help them take over Libya. Obama and the political left are not the only ones guilty of being a little squeamish when it comes to dealing with one of our staunchest allies.  President Bush held up the Bush Doctrine, which I agreed with by the way, and promptly showed the world that it did not apply to Israel.  They were the only nation in his world which was not only prohibited from presumptively dealing with terrorism, but required to show that wonderful restraint as well.  Bush 41, during the Gulf War, while stationing Patriot Batteries in Israel, threatened her to not retaliate when clearly attacked with Scud Missiles.  Carter and Clinton both legitimized the, “Palestinians,” by giving advice and comfort and a seat at the table to Yassar Arafat.  You may have noticed that I always refer to the, “Palestinians,” in quotes, this is because anyone who knows even the slightest thing about the region realizes that there is actually no such thing as a, “Palestinian People.” 

Part of the problem in this region, not only with Israel, but Lebanon, Libya, Egypt, Syria, and Iran also is a universal refusal to deal honestly with facts.  We are paralyzed from recognizing and dealing with the truth by a political correctness run amok.  When exactly, did it become out of vogue to call a thug a thug?  Not every society and culture is equal.  Clearly, a culture which allows for rape victims to be imprisoned for allowing themselves to be in the company of a male rapist while unmarried, and refuses to prosecute the rapist, is not on an equal footing with my culture.  Clearly, a culture which allows a woman to be stoned to death for the crime of being caught in public  with a non relative male companion is not on an equal footing with my culture.  Clearly, a culture which celebrates mass murder of school children and people dancing in night clubs is not on an equal footing with my culture.  Bigotry is wrong, discrimination is not.  For what ever reason, we in this great country gave up the ability to discriminate between good and evil, and it is costing us dearly. 

For any on the political left who are regular readers of this site, here is a challenge.  Name any time in world history when a lasting peace has been negotiated.  I may be wrong, but no one has ever been able to defeat this challenge.  A lasting peace has always needed at least one of the following three conditions to occur.  One, a convincing military defeat of one nation over another, two, mutually beneficial trade of goods and services between the two nations in question, three, one nation being overwhelmingly superior from a military strength standpoint, this is what will lead to peace, as it has throughout history.  You can call me out and dismiss me as a warmonger, chicken hawk, evil, or what have you.  Before you do that however, prove me wrong in the arena of ideas, and in the real world.  Name a single instance in world history where a lasting peace was negotiated.

Hat tip to NoThreat2U.

Crossposted at Musing of a Mad Conservative.

Goldstone Report has been disavowed by its own author, where does Israel now go to get its good name back?

by Mojambo ( 171 Comments › )
Filed under Gaza, IDF, Israel, Palestinians, United Nations at April 3rd, 2011 - 4:30 pm

Let’s face it, as Weasel Zippers says, Israel and the Jews are  always guilty until proven innocent, and even then that is not good enough for most of her detractors. The Goldstone Report was an”Alice in Wonderland” type of fiasco with its “sentence first, trial later” attitude towards Israel. To all those Western nations whose default position is to “blame Israel first”, I say today it is Israel, tomorrow it will be you. Thanks a lot Judge Goldstone – now do the honorable thing and go off your self.  As Scott Johnson  from Powerline blog writes  “The South African jurist Richard Goldstone is a fool and a knave. He lent his name to a lengthy report issued under the auspices of the United Nations Human Rights Council. The report accused Israel of massive war crimes in the war Israel waged against Hamas in 2008-2009, commenced by Israel after Hamas and friends had fired more than 12,000 rockets at Israel (every one of which was criminal).

by Tovah Lazaroff and Yaakov Katz

Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu called on the United Nations Saturday night to disavow the Goldstone Report alleging war crimes by the IDF in Gaza two years ago after its author said he had erroneously accused Israel of intentionally targeting civilians.

“The fact that [South African jurist Richard] Goldstone backtracked must lead to the shelving of this report once and for all,” Netanyahu said in a statement to the press.

Israel had refused to cooperate with Goldstone’s fact-finding mission into its military operation in Gaza in December 2008 and January 2009, known as Operation Cast Lead, and rejected the September 2009 report, which accused Israel and Hamas of war crimes and possible crimes against humanity and suggested that the matter be referred to the International Court of Justice if Israel did not hold follow-up investigations into the matter.

Israel charged that the report, which focused largely on its actions in Gaza, was biased and flawed. But it has held investigations into Operation Cast Lead.

“Everything we said has proven true,” Netanyahu said on Saturday night.

“Israel did not intentionally harm civilians. Its institutions and investigative bodies are worthy, while Hamas intentionally fired upon innocent civilians and did not examine anything,” he said.

The absurdity here, Netanyahu added, was that the UN Human Rights Council, the body that called for the report, had Libya as a member.

“It’s time to throw this report into the dustbin of history,” he said.

Defense Minister Ehud Barak, who held that post during Operation Cast Lead, said that Goldstone should send his new conclusions to the same international forums “in which he published his twisted and nonfactual report.”

“Only that way can there be a partial correction of the damage that was caused,” he explained.

Both Netanyahu and Barak spoke after Goldstone published an opinion piece in Friday’s The Washington Post in which he said: “If I had known then what I know now, the Goldstone Report would have been a different document.”

Goldstone said the fact-finding mission’s allegations that Israel took actions which intentionally led to the death and injury of civilians, were based on the information available to him at the time.

Investigations conducted by the Israeli military into those incidents, which have been recognized by the UN, “indicate that civilians were not intentionally targeted as a matter of policy.” Goldstone noted in particular the work of the UN Human Rights Council’s panel, which monitors compliance with the report and delivered its own assessment of the matter to the council in its March session.

[…]

Benayahu said that the IDF made some mistakes during the operation and has investigated all of them.

He warned, however, that Hamas and Hezbollah were already establishing their military infrastructure inside population centers and that the world needed to be prepared for the consequences in the event of a future war with Israel.

“We knew how to locate the mistakes even before we heard the name Richard Goldstone.

We did this for Israel and the Jewish people, and not for the world,” he said.

Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman said on Channel 2’s Meet the Press that he was not surprised by Goldstone’s statements.

“We had no doubt that the truth would come out eventually,” said Lieberman.

Goldstone actually came to the same conclusions that the two follow-up committees to the Goldstone committee came to, he said, namely that Israel’s court system acted objectively and professionally in investigating allegations of war crimes.

In addition, both Goldstone and the follow-up committees agreed that Hamas had done nothing to address allegations of war crimes or human rights violations that the Goldstone report accused them of during Operation Cast Lead.

[…]

Read the rest: Netanyahu: Throw Goldstone Report on the dust bin of history